Book Review: I Am Princess X, by Cherie Priest

I Am Princess X is incredibly riveting and clever, although it loses a lot of its narrative daring about two-thirds of the way through. This would be a bigger problem if not for the fact that you can read the whole book in just a few hours – it’s short and fast-moving. So by the time you get to the more conventional style you are almost done with the book anyway.

Libby and May became best friends when they were both nine, and they started writing a series of comics and stories about Princess X. May wrote the stories and Libby drew the pictures. A few years later, Libby and her mom died in a car accident. But a few years after the accident, May starts seeing “I Am Princess X” stickers everywhere and she discovers a webcomic that clearly refers to her and Libby. Is Libby alive?

The book combines the format of a novel and the comic format, as May reads the comic for clues. Eventually the comic format is largely dropped – which is unfortunate, because the parts of the story told in comic format are incredibly effective and scary. The book suffers when it becomes less of a mystery and more a straight forward catch the bad guy story.

There are some missteps in the book in addition to the change in style. One odd thing about the book is its insistence on explaining pretty basic terms. Honestly, this book is aimed at teens. Are there any teens who don’t know what “Dropbox” is? Also, May finds an ally who is a hacker. He is in trouble because he was, frankly, a criminal douchebag to his ex-girlfriend. I never liked this character but I felt like I was supposed to like him even though he expresses no remorse and no acknowledgement of how harmful his actions towards his ex would have been had he not gotten caught. A reformed jerk has to, you know, reform. They have to take responsibility for their past actions, not just try to clean up with new ones. His character was so weirdly drawn that I felt like there was a subplot involving him being a villain that was dropped.

Still, the book is well-worth checking out just for the first two-thirds of the book, which is inventive, mysterious, horrifying, exciting, and moving. I had literal chills as certain clues were revealed and I was just desperate to figure out what was going on. If there’s a sequel, I’ll read it. As much as I love to read romance, I was thrilled that this YA does NOT include a romance. It keeps the focus on the friendship between Libby and May.